Crumbl Buckeye Brownie Cookies Copycat Recipe

Last wee, Crumbl released their insane buckeye brownie cookies. Think a thick brownie cookie topped with the Buckeye peanut butter mixture, and coated with melted semi-sweet chocolate goodness. Drooling yet?!

The combination of the thick chocolate cookies and the smooth peanut butter topping is absolutely to die for, so don’t blame yourself if you drooled all over reading this or looking at the photos!

This is the best holiday cookie, AKA Crumbl buckeye brownie cookie recipe!

Raise your hands if you love buckeyes! Now, raise your hands if you love cookies! Better yet, raise your hands if you love chocolate brownie cookies with buckeye topping.

If you did all three, or just the last one, this copycat cookies recipe is the only one you’ll ever need! I promise! Seriously that good.

Why you need to make this recipe!

• It’s the best recipe for chocolate peanut butter lovers
• These cookies are perfect for Christmas and the holiday season.
• It’s easy to make.
• They taste just like the Crumbl version.
• Thanks to these you can have your favorite cookies year round!

Ingredients for this Crumbl Buckeye cookie recipe

Here are the ingredients you will need to make this peanut butter buckeye brownie cookie. Make sure to scroll down to the recipe card for the full detailed ingredient measurements.

• Butter– You can use either salted or unsalted butter for this recipe.
• Brown sugar– The brown sugar is the main sweetening agent that will keep the cookies extra soft and chewy.
• Granulated sugar- The granulated sugar is what makes the cookie edges a little crispy.
• Egg– The egg is the binding agent for these cookies, the yolk also adds extra fat for mositure.
• Vanilla extract– The vanilla extract helps bring out the chocolate flavor even more.
• Flour– You will need all purpose flour for this cookie recipe.
• Dutch processed cocoa powder– The dutch processed cocoa powder will give a nice chocolatey flavor.
• Baking soda– The baking soda will give you extra height to your cookies.
• Salt– The salt will balance out the sweetness of the cookies.
• Chocolate chips– Make sure to use good quality chocolate chips for these cookies.
• Peanut butter– I use creamy Skippy peanut butter for thi spart.
• Powdered sugar– The powdered sugar will be mixed with the peanut butter to create the Buckeye topping.

How to make Crumbl Buckeye brownie cookies?

This is how you can make these buckeye cookies. Make sure to scroll down to the recipe card for the full detailed instructions!

1. Cream the butter, and both sugars until fluffy.
2. Add in the egg and vanilla extract and mix.
3. Combine the dry ingredients into the wet mixture and mix until the flour mixture disappears.
4. Scoop out your cookie dough balls, place them on a baking sheet and gently press down to about 1 inch in thickness.
5. Bake in the preheated oven, let them cool down on the baking sheet for 10 minutes, then transfer to a cooling rack.

Make the peanut butter buckeye topping

• Mix the peanut butter, butter, sugar, and vanilla together until a thick paste forms.
• Divide the peanut butter mixture into 7 equally sized balls.
• Top each cooled down cookie with the peanut butter mixture, and press to flatten.
• Top with the melted semi sweet chocolate and enjoy!

Chocolate topped cookies!

Now hear me out, you don’t have to top your cookies with as much melted chocolate as I did, but you definitely can. It makes them that much more fun and drool-worthy.

You can enjoy these cookies with the chocolate melted or you can chill them and enjoy them with the chocolate solidified like the OG buckeye balls!

Frequently asked questions – FAQ

What is a buckeye?

Technically a buckeye is a dark brown nut, but since we’re talking treats, it’s a confection made out of peanut butter, powdered sugar, and butter then dipped in chocolate.

It’s pretty much a peanut butter fudge ball that is coated in chocolate to look like a buckeye nut.

How can I store Crumbl buckeye brownie cookies?

These cookies can be stored in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 4 days.

You can also store them in an airtight container in the fridge for up to a week. Depending on if you like them cold or room temp, you might have to pull them out of the fridge and let them sit at room temperature for a little bit.

These cookies can also be frozen in an airtight container for up to 2 months.

Once you’re ready to enjoy them, let them thaw in the fridge overnight.

Can I double this recipe?

Absolutely! If you want to make these cookies for a crowd or to give in Christmas cookie boxes you can definitely double or triple the recipe.

The cool thing about this is that you can click x2 or x3 in the recipe card and see the ingredient measurements change for you automatically.

Crumbl Buckeye Brownie cookies

If you made these Crumbl buckeye brownie cookies and enjoyed them, don’t forget to leave a 5-star review by clicking on the 5 stars under the title and description. It would help me a ton 

Thank you for making it all the way down here 🙂

If you enjoyed this recipe don’t forget to let us know in the comments below! In the meantime, don’t forget to follow me on Instagram!

Shop this recipe

This post may contain affiliate posts, meaning that at no cost to you I will get a small percentage of every purchase you make!

If you enjoyed this Crumbl Buckeye brownie cookies recipe make sure to pin it for later!