The Best Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream Recipe

Since you are here, make sure to check out my high protein cottage cheese edible cookie dough, this high protein chocolate cherry protein shake, as well as this high protein peach banana smoothie, and this high protein chocolate chip cookie in the microwave. For more ninja creami ice cream recipes check out this recipe collection article. 

This is the best ninja creami protein ice cream 

The Ninja Creami ice cream maker is still all the rage even after a whole year or being on the market and that for good reason! It is able to take a high protein drink and turn it into the most delicious creamy ice cream that will both satisfy your cravings and help you attain your protein goals. 

I personally use this as part of my healthy snacks ration to never get bored and satisfy my sweet tooth when I am feeling ice cream. 

The best part is that you can literally enjoy the whole pint without consuming too much sugar or fat. You’ll also be left full and extra satisfied. Homemade ice cream never felt this good and now thanks to the Ninja Creami we can have a creamy texture ice cream with benefits!

Why you need to make this recipe!

• You can have the entire pint of ice cream and still stay within your nutritional goals!
• This ice cream comes with 30 grams of protein per batch. 
• It’s a great way to satisfy your sweet tooth while getting in that extra protein. 
• You can really get creative with this recipe because it shows you a great protein ice cream base but the final product is up to you. Change flavors and mix-ins and create some magic. 

Ingredients for this protein ice cream recipe 

Here are the simple ingredients you will need to make this healthy ice cream recipe. Make sure to scroll down to the recipe card for the full detailed ingredient measurements.

• Chocolate Protein Shake: I use bottled protein shake like Fair Life to make my life easier for this specific recipe. Feel free to use your favorite protein shake bottle that comes already premade to recreate this healthy treat. 
• Instant pudding– This will add extra creaminess to your high protein ice cream.
• Mix-ins

How to make the best Fairlife Ninja Creami ice cream recipe at home

This is how you can make this delicious chocolate ice cream. Make sure to scroll down to the recipe card for the full detailed instructions! 

1. Pour your protein shake into the ninja creami pint container to the max fill line, add in one tablespoon of instant pudding thenclose the lid and freeze for 24 hours. 
2. Once ready to enjoy your ice cream place the creami pint container in the outer bowl of the ninja creami machine and close the lid then attach it to the motor base and spin it on the lite ice cream button.
3. The first spin will yield a crumbly mixture, just add 2-3 tablespoons of milk of your choice of more protein shake then respin to get the right creamy consistency. 
4. Add your mix-ins then spin one more time on spin setting then enjoy your delicious sweet treat. The texture of this ice cream is absolutely unbelievable, so I hope you love it as much as we did!

Frequently asked questions – FAQ

How to store this ninja cream ice cream?

It’s very simple, once you have finished enjoying your ice cream, put the lid back on and place back in the freezer. 

Whenever you are ready to enjoy it again, place the pint of frozen ice cream in your ninja creami ice cream machine and blend again. 

Can I turn this into a vanilla ice cream?

You definitely can. For a matter of fact you can actually make this ice cream any flavor depending on your protein shake. You can use the core power strawberry or vanilla protein shakes for a treat that is even higher in protein. Add in your favorite toppings and enjoy it as a late night snack or afternoon pick me up to keep you going throughout the day. 

What mix-ins can I add to this ice cream base?

Whatever your heart desires honestly! I know that mix-ins are th best part of ice cream so let’s get into it. When it comes to chocolate ice cream here are some of my favorites:

• Smooth or crunchy peanut butter
• Chocolate chips
• Hot fudge sauce
• Caramel sauce
• Oreo pieces
• Cookie dough chunks
• Chocolate sprinkles
• Mini marshmallows
• Toasted coconuts 
• Reese’s peanut butter cups

Where can I find the protein shakes used in this recipe?

I used the Fairlife shakes, they have them in multiple different flavors but I used the chocolate flavor to make chocolate ice cream. You can find these at your local grocery stores or you can also get them in bulk at Costco or Sam’s Club

Can I make this protein ice cream with protein powder?

I enjoy making this ice cream with the bottled protein shake because it is so quick and convenient but you can definitely make it using protein powder as well. 

All you have to do is add about 14 ounces of milk into the pint container. I like using the fair life milk because it comes with a little added protein then mix in a scoop of protein powder of choice and a tablespoon of sugar free instant pudding mix using a hand held frother. 

Freeze for 24 hours and blend using the lite ice cream feature. 

How long does it take to make ice cream in the Ninja ice cream maker?

The thing that will take the longest when making ice cream with your Ninja Creami machine is the actual freezing part. That takes a minimum of 12 hours but it is suggested by the Ninja brand to freeze your mixture for 24 hours before blending. 

The blending then takes about 4-5 minutes, especially when you have to rebound the ice cream to get it to that right consistency as well as blend to incorporate the mix-ins.

The Best Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream Recipe

If you enjoyed this high protein Ninja Creami chocolate ice cream recipe make sure to pin it for later!